Making Butter at Home

Yesterday I was making butter (if you follow me on Instagram, you would have seen it!) when it occurred to me that I haven’t written about that yet.

Now, when I say I made butter, it’s not entirely from scratch. I didn’t milk the cow, skimming the cream from the fresh milk. I bought a carton of cream from the supermarket. Really, all the hard work was done by the dairy farmer (and the cow), my part is easy!

You can use pure cream or thickened cream for this, although thickened cream of course has additives. But it will have a heck of a lot less additives than the margarine you may have in the fridge.

*Important* – You just can’t use light or low fat cream. Check the bottle – it will say not suitable for whipping. And that’s what we’re going to be doing with it.

And if you ever see bottles of cream marked down, this is a great way to use them 🙂

The bottle on the left is marked down thickened cream, on the right is (full price) pure cream. They are both 600ml.

Cream for butter

Pour your cream into your electric mixer, and start whipping. And keep on whipping.

You can, of course, use a handheld electric mixer, or even a completely non-electric whisk. You will also develop nicely toned arms at the same time! For this job, I am more than happy to drag out the big mixer…

First up, you get -surprise, surprise – whipped cream! Don’t stop – keep going!

Cream to butter

It depends on how fast you have your beaters going , but I’ve found that at around 15 minutes the cream starts separating. You can see liquid pooling

Cream - butter

And there’s your butter! But you’re not quite done yet. Next you need to drain off the whey, or buttermilk.

Line a bowl with a clean cloth, I use a clean kitchen chux. Scoop out the butter and buttermilk into the chux, and let it drain.


Gather up the sides of the chux around the butter and squeeze all the liquid out. Don’t throw the liquid away!

It’s very important then to rinse your lump of butter under cold water. Keep it wrapped in the cloth, and squeeze the water through it. Keep rinsing until the water runs clear. Removing all the buttermilk from the butter will keep your it fresher for longer. This is why you can use short-dated cream to make butter, and not have it go off quickly.

But the buttermilk is still good to use. Add it in your milkshakes or smoothies. Use it in your baking. Many recipes call for buttermilk, but you can also substitute it for plain milk. It will make your pancakes or pikelets, cakes and slices light and fluffy. And it can be frozen if you can’t use it straight away.

So, what did I get from 600ml of cream?

butter and buttermilk

As you can see, I ended up with about 230g of butter, and around 1 cup of buttermilk.

You can leave it that, but you know how hard it is to spread pure butter straight from the fridge? We can fix that! Put your butter back in your mixer and start beating again, this time slowly drizzling in some olive oil (or your preferred oil type). You’ll have to experiment with how much is required, but it’s not too much. Maybe 1/4 cup.

You can also add some salt. Or go all out and make flavoured butter with garlic and/or herbs, or whatever else you choose!

I used some of the buttermilk to make pikelets for afternoon tea. Topped with some of the butter, and some homemade plum jam, they were delicious! And plenty left over to go in the school lunch box 🙂


The rest of the buttermilk I used in these chocolate cupcakes. I substituted it for the plain milk that the recipe called for. They will be frozen, also for school lunchbox treats.

Cupcake with buttermilk

If you haven’t made butter before, you really should give it a try. It is very easy to do, tastes great, and you know exactly what is in it.

I know many of you have made butter. Do you have any tips I’ve missed?

Linking up with:

Milk and Cuddles – Mommy Club, 21 Rosemary Lane – Share Your Style, Too Much Time on my Hands – The Handmade Hangout, Posed Perfection – Creative Ways, Have a Daily Cup of Mrs Olson – Share Your Cup, Domesblissity – Thriving on Thursdays, Wondermom Wannabe – This is How We Roll, Sincerely, Paula – No Rules Weekend Blog Party, The Life of Jennifer Dawn – A Little Bird Told Me, The Pin Junkie, Life With Lorelei – Home Matters, Shoestring Elegance – What to do Weekends, Tatertots and Jello – Link Party PaloozaOh My Heartsie Girl – Friday Features, Strawberry Butterscotch – Saturday Shuffle, 24 Cottonwood Lane – Best of the Weekend, Love of Home – Sundays at Home, The Pinterested Parent – Sunday’s Best, Nifty Thrifty Things, My Husband Has Too Many Hobbies – Snickerdoodle Sunday, That Recipe – Happiness is Homemade, Plucky’s Second Thought – Cooking and Crafting With J&J, My Pinterventures – Merry Monday, Claire Justine – Creative Mondays, Create With Joy – Inspire Me Monday, I Should Be Mopping the Floor – Inspiration Monday, Embellishmints – Dream. Create. Inspire, Yesterday on Tuesday – Project Inspired, The DIY Mommy – The Creative Corner, Lou Lou Girls, Kathe With an E – You’re Gonna Love It, Our Home Away From Home – Tuesdays at Our Home,  Being a Wordsmith – Turn it Up Tuesday, The Dedicated House – Make it Pretty Monday, Cedar Hill Farmhouse – The Scoop, That Recipe – Tasty Tuesday, The DIY Dreamer – From Dream to Reality, Oh My Heartsie Girl – Wonderful Wednesday, Savvy Southern Style – Wow Us Wednesday, Simply Made Fun – Wednesday Roundup, Lamberts Lately – Create it Thursday,


15 thoughts on “Making Butter at Home

  1. Pingback: Dedicated House Sunday Showcase Make Pretty Monday Party

  2. Pingback: Thriving on Thursdays - Linky Party # 192 - Domesblissity

  3. Hi I’m Anne from Birdsong Bits and Pieces (, and I found you through the Turn it up Tuesday blog hop. Glad to see you had success. I never have. I haven’t tried it from store-bought cream though. I used to buy fresh milk from an Amish farm near me, and I tried making butter a couple times but it never turned out right. Maybe I’ll try again following your instructions! Have a great day…


    • Hi Anne, thanks for ‘finding’ me! I’ve returned your fb like 🙂
      You are lucky being able to buy fresh milk straight from the farm! I am no expert, but I would think milk doesn’t have enough fat in it to whip up. Skimming the cream from the top of the milk would probably work better. Or buy cream from the shop lol
      Let me know if you try it again, hopefully successfully xx Fiona


  4. Good on you Fiona. I’ve done this so many times, unintentionally of course, when I’ve over whipped cream but I’d love to try it for real. I think I might just give it a go. It looks and sounds delicious. Thanks for sharing at Thriving on Thursdays last week. I’m featuring this one at tomorrow’s party.

    Anne xx


Thanks for visiting my blog! I'd love to know what you think of my posts, so please leave a comment xx Fiona

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.